So my wife and I went sailing for our second time on our Prindle 16. The boat handled great in the 8-13mph winds off Honeymoon Island, FL. The started the afternoon off sailing North, into the wind (wind was coming from the NNE early and shifted to more NE), (by a suggestion of another cat sailor).
We made some great speed close hauled and reaching. On our way back down south, we tried to get the cat into a broad reach (expect great speed) but every time we did, the jib would start flapping and the tell-tales on the main sail would flutter on the back side. As soon as we turned the boat into more of a reach, the tell tales would straighten out and the jib would catch the wind. At one point I had the mainsheet and jib sheet all the way out but it just didn't matter as we would immediately start to lose speed and have the same issues.
What were we doing wrong? I am hoping to get the cat out once more this fall before the weather gets too cold (70 is much to cold for me)