I've had a bunch of different boats, and I suspect I know the answer, but my purpose is to find the best cheap cat to sail around the islands of beautiful east Penobscot Bay in Maine. The archipelago of islands there contain the "Island Trail" with great places to beach with only bay-like small waves, but the catch is the big tides and shoals. Also some rocky beaches.
So I want the best non board, preferably light boat, for this mission. I've owned a P-18 and 18-2, loved them both, but the Nacra models seem to have even more buoyancy and simplicity. The 5.7/570 seems best to me, but they're in super short supply. A decent 5.0 is available. I'm thinking about getting the 5.0 as a place holder for the 5.7, should I ever find one. Rugged skegs better than a P-18? Does the extra length make that big a difference? Thoughts? Thanks in advance...
Old boat comparison: Nacra 5.0 vs 5.7 or Prindle 18?
-
- Rank: Lubber
- Registered: Apr 25, 2011
- Last visit: Aug 27, 2023
- Posts: 13
Posted: Aug 14, 2023 - 06:31 PM
-
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Apr 07, 2017
- Last visit: Nov 21, 2024
- Posts: 367
Posted: Aug 14, 2023 - 08:40 PM
One or two on this boat? That'll determine the answer between an 18ft or a 16 ft. If rugged is a priority, consider a Hobie Getaway. Heavier and slower yes, but tougher and front tramp as a bonus.
--
Bill Townsend
G-Cat 5.0
Sarasota
-- -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Jul 29, 2015
- Last visit: Jul 26, 2024
- Posts: 590
Posted: Aug 14, 2023 - 09:01 PM
I have owned my 5.7 since 1986 and have sailed in the Atlantic, Pacific, and several of the Great Lakes. It delivers good performance and durability and is fairly easy to beach in difficult conditions. Obviously its old, but has been given a new composite Kevlar/Glass Epoxy bottom and Interlux Perfection paint, standing and running rigging, several tramps, sails and other upgrades over the years. It's a great boat with stability and good speed, but heavier than modern versions. It has passed through some gales and breaking off-shore surf, but I have aged more than the boat and no longer go on the double traps or take risks like I did 35 years ago. It's still ready, but I'm not. These boats come up every once in a while, and it's probably worth investing some work in the ones that have not been kept up to date.
--
Tom
NACRA 5.7 (1984 Sail 181)
Pennsylvania
-- -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Nov 22, 2012
- Last visit: Nov 20, 2024
- Posts: 410
Posted: Aug 17, 2023 - 12:55 PM
Things to consider: what crew weight are you anticipating? Not particularly for speed, but are you thinking of having 1,2, or 3 people on the boat? If you are in the 150-170# range and expect to have you and one other, the 5.0 may be best. I used to have a 5.0 (and did add a N5.8 rig on it and a 9' rack on the side for a particular regatta) and it is limited on buoyancy. Between the P18 and the N5.7, it really depends on what is available and a few differences: wanna go boomless? Do you like the Prindle or Nacra rudders better? Do you like the deck lip on the 18 or do you want a smoother hull like the Nacra? It will depend on the condition of each you find. The boomless is convenient and we have a local 5.8 that added a boom. I would only go with the 5.0 if the mast of the 5.7 or 18 is difficult to deal with. I think you'll enjoy the buoyancy of the bigger boats more as you cruise the area.
--
Scott
Prindle Fleet 2
TCDYC
Prindle 18-2 Mod "FrankenKitty"
Tornado Classic "Fast Furniture"
Prindle 19 "Mr. Wiggly"
Nacra 5.8 "De ja vu"
Nacra 5.0
Nacra 5.8
Tornadoes (Reg White)
-- -
- Rank: Chief
- Registered: Nov 26, 2009
- Last visit: Aug 10, 2024
- Posts: 2531
Posted: Aug 17, 2023 - 10:13 PM
We run both a 5.7 and a 5.0
Both handle two medium weight adults.
What is your wind situation?
The 5.0 is a bit under canvassed, it comes alive with 15mph wind, 20 rocks.
If winds are lighter in your area, the 5.7 wins hands down.
Both take about the same effort to right.
One other consideration…how do you store it? Both Nacras beat my H18 hands down for raiding or lowering the sail. I store on modified Seadoo lifts, & cannot turn them to be “into the wind”. The Nacra sails can be raised, & lowered easily, even with the sail against the shrouds.
Edited by Edchris177 on Aug 17, 2023 - 10:15 PM.
--
Hobie 18 Magnum
Dart 15
Mystere 6.0XL Sold Was a handful solo
Nacra 5.7
Nacra 5.0
Bombardier Invitation (Now officially DEAD)
Various other Dock cluttering WaterCrap
-- -
- Rank: Lubber
- Registered: Apr 25, 2011
- Last visit: Aug 27, 2023
- Posts: 13
Posted: Aug 20, 2023 - 11:36 PM
Ah, nice responses all, thank you!
So as for weight, I'm about 170, crew would be lighter, but I'm not authorized to disclose numbers. Occasionally I'll be going solo, so the smaller boats should be adequate weightwise. For winds, Maine summer winds generally are light, 10-ish knots or less. I've heard the 5.0 is undercanvassed also. I'll be keeping the boat on a beach, but the tides here are big, so lighter is preferred. No matter what it is, a winch will be involved, but still, lighter is better.
New in the mix, someone has a Supercat for sale locally, also older (1982), no board or boom, and some great engineering. Asking price is $3,500 for that, seems good structurally, but not very pretty cosmetically. When I add up new sails, either my time or someone else's for detailing, odds and ends, very soon it's a $6k boat or more and there are some very nice boats in that price range, newer but not boardless. Big thing about the boards is there are shoals here which I'd either have to learn where they all are or use my phone for a plotter or risk a big whack if I hit one.
Quite the dilemma.... -
- Rank: Lubber
- Registered: Apr 25, 2011
- Last visit: Aug 27, 2023
- Posts: 13
Posted: Aug 20, 2023 - 11:52 PM
Supercat 17, to be more specific... -
- Rank: Lubber
- Registered: Jul 20, 2016
- Last visit: Jan 15, 2024
- Posts: 56
Posted: Aug 21, 2023 - 07:42 AM
Per your requirements (non board, preferably light boat), the 5.0 will be lighter and a more modern hull shape. You could have a slightly larger main built and solve the under canvassed problem. S17 is heavy in comparison. The 5.0 won't scare the "not authorized to disclose numbers" person. Take a righting bag with you for solo sailing. Have fun on your quest!
Bob
--
Master UniRig Sailor
-- -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Nov 25, 2015
- Last visit: Jul 17, 2024
- Posts: 661
Posted: Aug 21, 2023 - 04:08 PM
Even under canvased, I still love the 5.0.
--
John
Nacra 5.0
CT
-- -
- Rank: Lubber
- Registered: Apr 25, 2011
- Last visit: Aug 27, 2023
- Posts: 13
Posted: Aug 21, 2023 - 09:51 PM
Good to hear, John. What makes you love the 5.0?
Roger to Bob on scaring the "undisclosed number" crew as well. She puts up with a lot of my water shenanigans, but her limits are well below mine.
The Supercat 17 looks like a beast. Everything currently on the market around here is 1980s vintage. Where are all the other boats???
Does the 5.0 have a square top mainsail option for older boats? Would a 500 sail help? Honestly, for the wicked cold water environment up heyah in Maine bay and ocean water, slightly undercanvassed is probably a good thing. Water temp yesterday was 61 degrees in Stonington, about as warm as it will get probably. So a righting exercise needs to be expeditious. -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Feb 10, 2016
- Last visit: Jun 08, 2024
- Posts: 197
Posted: Aug 22, 2023 - 12:59 PM
As a current 500 owner I 2nd the opinion of John...5.0 is the way to go. Too bad you weren't in the market a few weeks ago as there was a nice 87 5.0 on here for sale for $1500. It was up in NJ too so not far from you. Keep your eyes pealed for another one.
--
Pete
2001 NACRA 450 SOLD
2000 NACRA 500 TOTAL LOSS
2004 NACRA INTER 20 SOLD
2016 NACRA 500 Sport
DeLand, FL
-- -
- Rank: Lubber
- Registered: Apr 25, 2011
- Last visit: Aug 27, 2023
- Posts: 13
Posted: Aug 22, 2023 - 02:50 PM
Thanks Pete - what's better about the 500? There's a 5.0 in my general area that I haven't seen yet, but from teh serial number, it's early 80's, I forget when. Owner says good condition, but "retro 1980's look".
I assume the 5.0 is like other older boats which have heavy loads ahead of the forward beam in particular? Any other spots unique to that boat to focus on? -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Feb 10, 2016
- Last visit: Jun 08, 2024
- Posts: 197
Posted: Aug 22, 2023 - 03:05 PM
So I believe the hull shape is the same on 5.0 and 500. 500 has a modified rudder system and they moved the jib blocks to the front crossbar. Square top Main...not sure of any other differences really. Now the brand new 500 has a newer wave piercing hull as does the new 570. I would look the hulls over really well and do a sound test for any soft spots. Plan on upgrading sails no matter what...they are your engine and yes I would go to a newer square top main if it was me.
--
Pete
2001 NACRA 450 SOLD
2000 NACRA 500 TOTAL LOSS
2004 NACRA INTER 20 SOLD
2016 NACRA 500 Sport
DeLand, FL
-- -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Apr 07, 2017
- Last visit: Nov 21, 2024
- Posts: 367
Posted: Aug 22, 2023 - 05:55 PM
There's another important difference between the 5.0 and the 500. The 500, and all Nacras for that matter, have switched to rectangular shaped cross beams. Structurally much better and also much easier to put the boat together and take it apart. Large bolts and threaded inserts inside the hulls. Big compression tubes that encircle the inside of the cross beam. No more straps. The jib blocks on the main beam aren't on every model but I'm not really sure. But that set up frees up space on the tramp but requires the foot of the jib to be cut with the tack much higher than the clew. Also, there's no fore and aft adjustment for the jib blocks which is important, but there's ways around that.
--
Bill Townsend
G-Cat 5.0
Sarasota
-- -
- Rank: Lubber
- Registered: Apr 25, 2011
- Last visit: Aug 27, 2023
- Posts: 13
Posted: Aug 22, 2023 - 09:40 PM
Good points Pete and Bill. Now find me a good relatively new one for sale cheap driven by a little old man (or lady) to church on Sundays and I'll be set! -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Feb 10, 2016
- Last visit: Jun 08, 2024
- Posts: 197
Posted: Aug 23, 2023 - 10:03 AM
Good point about the cross beams and the construction of them...it's true for sure. But my jib blocks do have adjustments in the cross beam. They can be moved closer to the mast to tighten the slot. There are 3 pre determined positions for the Jib Blocks.
--
Pete
2001 NACRA 450 SOLD
2000 NACRA 500 TOTAL LOSS
2004 NACRA INTER 20 SOLD
2016 NACRA 500 Sport
DeLand, FL
-- -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Apr 07, 2017
- Last visit: Nov 21, 2024
- Posts: 367
Posted: Aug 23, 2023 - 12:09 PM
Yes, but they cannot be moved fore and aft. When close hauled, you want an imaginary line extending from the jib sheet that bisects the sail area of the jib. Also as you fall off the wind, the jib twists off losing efficiency of the upper half. Now, Nacra jibs are very small, so it probably really doesn't make much difference especially if a spinnaker is involved. But when close hauled, if your lower telltales stream properly and the upper ones don't, attach the tack of the jib to a pennant. Just by raising the jib a couple of inches will have a profound effect on your sail trim, doing the same thing as moving the jib blocks forward.
--
Bill Townsend
G-Cat 5.0
Sarasota
-- -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Feb 10, 2016
- Last visit: Jun 08, 2024
- Posts: 197
Posted: Aug 23, 2023 - 12:24 PM
Good to know...Thanks! Sorry we got off topic...
Edited by saltlife77 on Aug 23, 2023 - 01:49 PM.
--
Pete
2001 NACRA 450 SOLD
2000 NACRA 500 TOTAL LOSS
2004 NACRA INTER 20 SOLD
2016 NACRA 500 Sport
DeLand, FL
-- -
- Rank: Lubber
- Registered: Apr 25, 2011
- Last visit: Aug 27, 2023
- Posts: 13
Posted: Aug 23, 2023 - 10:06 PM
No, it's good info. So why does the Supercat 17 get so little attention when it appears to be a faster and pioneering designed boat? Looking up the weight specs, it appears to be the same as the 5.0. The reason I'm asking is locally, amazingly enough, it appears I'll have a choice of those two. The better condition boat will get the nod, but they are likely similar, but I haven't finished my inspecting.
Searching, people have raved about the SC17. Has anyone sailed both for a comparison?
Thanks again! --George -
- Rank: Mate
- Registered: Nov 25, 2015
- Last visit: Jul 17, 2024
- Posts: 661
Posted: Aug 24, 2023 - 06:50 AM
If you are ever in CT you can look mine over in detail.
Edited by ctcataman on Aug 24, 2023 - 08:04 AM.
--
John
Nacra 5.0
CT
--
Users on-line
- 0 users
This list is based on users active over the last 60 minutes.