Welcome Guest
Catamaran Sailing at TheBeachcats.com Logo
Notifications
Clear all

Gunboat G4 Foiling cabin boat

33 Posts
18 Users
0 Reactions
18.5 K Views
(@Anonymous 39832)
Posts: 3281
Topic starter
 
[#30725]

It was just about this time last year when we were all dazzled by the spectacle that was the Phantom and the N20FCS and GC32... now Gunboat has managed to make a cat that has berths, galley and a head fly... amazing.


 
Posted : April 12, 2015 2:25 pm
(@ronald-reeder)
Posts: 513
Member
 

Indeed, amazing.

But I doubt if the balance is correct. The hulls tend to lean a bit forward. Pitchpoling!

(and the crew look like a group posh chickens)


 
Posted : April 13, 2015 2:30 am
Jake Kohl
(@jake)
Posts: 11744
Three Star Admiral Registered
 
Originally Posted by northsea junkie
Indeed, amazing.

But I doubt if the balance is correct. The hulls tend to lean a bit forward. Pitchpoling!

(and the crew look like a group posh chickens)

I can vouch that at least some of the crew are quite experienced sailors and foilers. This is not a low budget or corner-cutting operation. I agree, though, it did seem a little bow-down for a lot of that video but it seemed to slice through the waves while staying on foil.

I think your impression of the people was one they were actively trying to portray (perhaps with a little

tongue in cheek

)...a relaxed foiling experience....whether that's reality or not, I guess time will tell.


 
Posted : April 13, 2015 8:01 am
(@Anonymous 12680)
Posts: 1113
 

I like how they cut in scenes at anchor in the midst of the foiling scenes. Makes it seem rather posh to go foiling.

Beautiful boat and quite the foiler.


 
Posted : April 13, 2015 9:22 am
(@Anonymous 39832)
Posts: 3281
Topic starter
 
Originally Posted by Jake
Originally Posted by northsea junkie
Indeed, amazing.

But I doubt if the balance is correct. The hulls tend to lean a bit forward. Pitchpoling!

(and the crew look like a group posh chickens)

I can vouch that at least some of the crew are quite experienced sailors and foilers. This is not a low budget or corner-cutting operation. I agree, though, it did seem a little bow-down for a lot of that video but it seemed to slice through the waves while staying on foil.

I think your impression of the people was one they were actively trying to portray (perhaps with a little

tongue in cheek

)...a relaxed foiling experience....whether that's reality or not, I guess time will tell.

The daggerboard wells have three separate fore-aft adjustable positions 31cm apart. They're using this one as the

test

to figure out the best position.


 
Posted : April 13, 2015 9:37 am
(@stank)
Posts: 5061
One Star Admiral Registered
 

anything that can foil at 20+ knots while blending my favorite beverage and has hot showers ready gets my vote (and money if I win the lottery)... regardless of how the bow looks <img src="<>/smile.gif" alt="smile" title="smile" height="15" width="15" />


 
Posted : April 13, 2015 9:47 am
(@Lost in Translation)
Posts: 69
Lubber Registered
 

In my experience, foiling a little bow down is more stable than foiling a little bow up. As the boat lifts in that attitude, it doesn't build towards increasing lift and spiraling up until crashing down. Oracle's AC72 often was a little bow down as well.

This is different from

foiling

with C boards in foil assist configurations where you want the bow up all the time and the sterns still planted in the water.

Maybe they want perfectly level flight, but I think they looked very good and very in control, something everyone will want and need when sailing a 3 ton, 40 foot cat.


 
Posted : April 13, 2015 10:35 am
Tony_F18
(@Tony_FX1)
Posts: 2315
Captain Registered
 
Originally Posted by northsea junkie
Indeed, amazing.

But I doubt if the balance is correct. The hulls tend to lean a bit forward. Pitchpoling!

(and the crew look like a group posh chickens)

I think it might look more bow down than it actually is due to the

fat

stern though.


 
Posted : April 13, 2015 1:50 pm
Todd A. Hart
(@team_cat_fever)
Posts: 3061
Captain Registered
 
Originally Posted by Lost in Translation
In my experience, foiling a little bow down is more stable than foiling a little bow up. As the boat lifts in that attitude, it doesn't build towards increasing lift and spiraling up until crashing down. Oracle's AC72 often was a little bow down as well.

This is different from

foiling

with C boards in foil assist configurations where you want the bow up all the time and the sterns still planted in the water.

Maybe they want perfectly level flight, but I think they looked very good and very in control, something everyone will want and need when sailing a 3 ton, 40 foot cat.

Bingo!


 
Posted : April 13, 2015 4:15 pm
F-18 5150
(@hobie18rich)
Posts: 1343
Member
 

Boat is upside down.
<img src=" https://scontent-lax.xx.fbcdn.net/h... 8e71e0c9635c4981237747f2&oe=55A295F0" alt="" />


 
Posted : April 18, 2015 3:57 pm
(@Anonymous 38725)
Posts: 5859
 
Originally Posted by F-18 5150
Boat is upside down.
<img src=" https://scontent-lax.xx.fbcdn.net/h... 8e71e0c9635c4981237747f2&oe=55A295F0" alt="" />

Yeahbut..think of the sunsets1


 
Posted : April 18, 2015 6:16 pm
Philip
(@pm)
Posts: 3376
Captain Registered
 
Originally Posted by Timbo
Originally Posted by F-18 5150
Boat is upside down.
<img src=" https://scontent-lax.xx.fbcdn.net/h... 8e71e0c9635c4981237747f2&oe=55A295F0" alt="" />

Yeahbut..think of the sunsets1

Insurance rates for foiling cruising cats just tripled


 
Posted : April 18, 2015 7:13 pm
Todd A. Hart
(@team_cat_fever)
Posts: 3061
Captain Registered
 

If you're on the cutting edge , ya might get cut.
It's righted and back at the dock. Nice to see that they were pushing it hard enough for that to happen.


 
Posted : April 18, 2015 9:06 pm
(@mikekrantz)
Posts: 819
Chief Registered
 

very cool that they were able to right with the mast and mainsail intact!


 
Posted : April 19, 2015 12:14 am
(@ronald-reeder)
Posts: 513
Member
 
Originally Posted by F-18 5150
Boat is upside down.
<img src=" https://scontent-lax.xx.fbcdn.net/h... 8e71e0c9635c4981237747f2&oe=55A295F0" alt="" />

That shows exactly my point which I made earlier.

This Gunboat is nothing more than an overdressed sports-catamaran. And like each sport catamaran, it can flip and it can pitchpole.
And when that happens it's a super-heavy unmanageable cat.

The original promo video, showing lounging white dressed yups drinking champagne during sailing, is foolish. They had no lifevests on, so they were all lucky to survive soaked on their capsized dreamboat.

This forum is fooled by this Gunboat mirage.


 
Posted : April 19, 2015 3:57 am
pepin
(@noyau)
Posts: 966
Master Chief Registered
 

It's apparently exactly the same failure mode as Paprec Virbac, the classical Extreme 40 capsizes, or the big off Team NZ got at the last america's cup: You can't dump an hydraulic mainsheet instantly.

I expect the G4 will be equipped with a tilt sensor linked to an instant mainsheet release of some sort in a very near future.


 
Posted : April 19, 2015 4:34 am
(@bacho)
Posts: 1502
Master Chief Registered
 

I read that gunboats had a automatic sheet release as a safety. Seems like I read PJ say that it would dump the sails before flying a hull when activated. I would guess it's something that can be overridden.

Seems they would really need a good/fast system on the G4.


 
Posted : April 19, 2015 8:14 am
pepin
(@noyau)
Posts: 966
Master Chief Registered
 

Watch the capsize video: no release of the main, it just went sideways…


 
Posted : April 19, 2015 2:37 pm
(@rodgers)
Posts: 328
Mate Registered
 

Dyslexic driver, maybe steering is slightly backwards when keeping the boat up on foils. Anyway they took that gust up instead of down from the get-go.

TNZ wasn't really the same. They have a sheet with a winch for letting the wing out. Their problem was no hydro to tack the wing. As i understand it, they had to physically tack the wing using hydraulic controls and that had a lot to do with how fast they could tack and jibe. It seemed to me they may have been bringing the boat through the eye of the wind partially using the wing.

If Ronald is correct about the no life jackets, they will probably start wearing them after this.


 
Posted : April 19, 2015 4:07 pm
Philip
(@pm)
Posts: 3376
Captain Registered
 

Agreed. You would think the helm had enough experience to not head up. Hard to tell in the video but it looks like he might have loaded up the lee rudder and lost authority due to ventilation. I would wager we'll see second generation rudders with a bigger winglet and more chord.


 
Posted : April 19, 2015 5:39 pm
(@mystere50xl)
Posts: 863
Chief Registered
 
Quote
I would wager we'll see second generation rudders with a bigger winglet and more chord.

And maybe a Hobie Bob mast float as big as a Volkswagon bus.


 
Posted : April 19, 2015 9:42 pm
(@rehmbo)
Posts: 541
Chief Registered
 
Originally Posted by P.M.
Hard to tell in the video but it looks like he might have loaded up the lee rudder and lost authority due to ventilation.

I agree - at about 40 seconds in on the wipeout video, you can see the windward rudder at a pretty high angle as the skipper tries to head down, but the boat doesn't respond. The rooster tail behind the lee rudder also tells the tale. Blowing the gennaker only worsens the pressure on the rudders, causing the boat to start heading up and over.


 
Posted : April 20, 2015 8:42 am
Jake Kohl
(@jake)
Posts: 11744
Three Star Admiral Registered
 

I don't know about the rooster tail, but you can see the leeward tiller arm twitching as the skipper presumably jerks the windward one trying to get it to turn down. I can't correlate the skipper's arm movements to the leeward tiller movement but that may be because the resolution of the skipper just isn't that great in the video.

This is a whole lot of

arm-chair

skippering, but I agree that the release of the genny didn't help the rudders maintain traction. The main (particularly the traveler) did get eased but it wasn't enough or in concert with the genny. (but, I would personally have a hard time hanging onto the winch wraps with the genny if presented with the same scenario)

You can get a better sense for the tiller arrangement with this photo.

[Linked Image]

It was exceptionally impressive that the rig remained intact minus a few broken battens.


 
Posted : April 20, 2015 10:03 am
(@stank)
Posts: 5061
One Star Admiral Registered
 

1) I liked that Gunboat isn't ashamed to post and/or isn't denying what happend

2) I liked watching the crew and their choice(s) when the boat was

gone

. The one dude hitting the mast looked bad, but the other guy just hanging until it went turtle was almost funny. Of course, I can only say that as it appears no one was seriously hurt.

3) I'm glad they are actually testing the limits of this boat. And I would like more information on how they righted it without a lot of damage. I suspect the G32 and some of our larger three-legged bretherin (F-28/F-31) may benefit.

4) If you're going to buy an amped-up foiling beachcat, you should probably know what you're doing (or have a big enough wallet to handle what may come...).

5) I hope Gunboat supplies free monogrammed towels to G4 crews. And...

6) you bet your a$$ I'd still buy one if I had the chance.


 
Posted : April 20, 2015 11:29 am
 Karl
(@sogncab)
Posts: 3551
Member
 
Originally Posted by waterbug_wpb
6) you bet your a$$ I'd still buy one if I had the chance.

Winner winner chicken dinner.


 
Posted : April 20, 2015 11:47 am
(@ronald-reeder)
Posts: 513
Member
 

Read the comment of Peter Johnson (founder of Gunboat and crewmember):

http://www.yachtingworld.com/blogs/... the-voiles-de-saint-barths-regatta-63593


 
Posted : April 21, 2015 2:15 am
(@david.ingram)
Posts: 3879
Captain Registered
 
Originally Posted by northsea junkie
Read the comment of Peter Johnson (founder of Gunboat and crewmember):

http://www.yachtingworld.com/blogs/... the-voiles-de-saint-barths-regatta-63593

Ah crap! Was Clean on the mainsheet!?


 
Posted : April 21, 2015 7:57 am
Jake Kohl
(@jake)
Posts: 11744
Three Star Admiral Registered
 
Originally Posted by David Ingram
Originally Posted by northsea junkie
Read the comment of Peter Johnson (founder of Gunboat and crewmember):

http://www.yachtingworld.com/blogs/... the-voiles-de-saint-barths-regatta-63593

Ah crap! Was Clean on the mainsheet!?

That deserves a +1


 
Posted : April 21, 2015 7:59 am
Todd A. Hart
(@team_cat_fever)
Posts: 3061
Captain Registered
 

 
Posted : April 21, 2015 1:03 pm
Tony_F18
(@Tony_FX1)
Posts: 2315
Captain Registered
 

Still want one...


 
Posted : April 22, 2015 3:52 pm
Page 1 / 2
Secret Link