Welcome Guest
Catamaran Sailing at TheBeachcats.com Logo
Notifications
Clear all

Nacra 5.2- your appraisal please

18 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
3,725 Views
(@PurdueZach)
Posts: 223
Mate Registered
Topic starter
 
[#3750]

Hey guys, I ran across this Nacra 5.2 earlier on craigslist. Would you mind telling me what you think about it? I'm concerned about the paint job and structural integrity of a '79 cat. I think the price is a little high too considering the condition is so unknown.

http://detroit.craigslist.org/wyn/boa/3780339939.html



 
Posted : May 13, 2013 5:23 am
yurdle
(@yurdle)
Posts: 800
Chief Registered
 

Price is a little high compared to most 5.2s (which are fairly common.) Paint is expensive, and could be, in part, the reason for the higher cost.

However, black paint.


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 5:53 am
Rob Hangen
(@rch701)
Posts: 396
Chief Registered
 

Two words. Keep shopping.


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 6:18 am
(@PurdueZach)
Posts: 223
Mate Registered
Topic starter
 

I figured this was probably a bad move.

Back to my craigslist browsing...


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 7:18 am
MN3
 MN3
(@mn3)
Posts: 7090
Member
 

$2500 does not seem out of range for a well maintained, newly painted boat.

If the sails are good, and the hulls are strong, and the trailer is in the shape it is claimed ... all seems reasonable to me.


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 7:31 am
Rob Hangen
(@rch701)
Posts: 396
Chief Registered
 

MN3 wrote: $2500 does not seem out of range for a well maintained, newly painted boat.

If the sails are good, and the hulls are strong, and the trailer is in the shape it is claimed ... all seems reasonable to me.

And if you like "Jet Black".


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 8:27 am
(@bacho)
Posts: 1502
Master Chief Registered
 

MN3 wrote: $2500 does not seem out of range for a well maintained, newly painted boat.

If the sails are good, and the hulls are strong, and the trailer is in the shape it is claimed ... all seems reasonable to me.

Except that its a 5.2


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 9:23 am
(@erice)
Posts: 1419
Member
 

any little scratch is going to show white...

$2.5k is halfway to something like a hobie tiger if you want a crewed boat, and you'd get your money back on that if you sold it next year...

for a solo boat you'd probably get a newer hobie17 for the same


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 9:46 am
Philip
(@pm)
Posts: 3376
Captain Registered
 

Zach,
Aren't you moving to Florida? Your arse will hate you, and disown you if you buy a black boat in Florida.


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 9:46 am
Philip
(@pm)
Posts: 3376
Captain Registered
 

Be a man and get a real boat. 🙄
http://www.thebeachcats.com/classifieds/catamarans/p12720-hobie-miracle-20.html
Of course you still will NOT experience the awesome . . .
"Chicks Dig Nacras" quandary . . . :schildbacktotopic:


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 9:54 am
Rob Vaden
(@redtwin)
Posts: 510
Chief Registered
 

mummp wrote: Zach,
Aren't you moving to Florida? Your arse will hate you, and disown you if you buy a black boat in Florida.

I'm no expert but the black could cause structural problems later because it is going to get ridiculously hot any time you sail it even if you do store it covered. I think it would get hot enough to start breaking down the hulls. Can anyone correct me if I am wrong?

I used to own a 5.2 and it was a great solo boat. I wanted to paint it blue but everyone I talked to told me I was nuts to do anything but white in Florida. I settled for a thick blue stripe down each hull. It was no where near as "pretty" as this boat but it was structurally sound. I sold it for $800. I've regretted it ever since.


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 10:32 am
(@windadict)
Posts: 153
Mate Registered
 

Zach,
Check this one out:

http://richmond.craigslist.org/boa/3803424638.html

...and I thought that I got good deal for my Nacra 5.0 last year...


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 3:30 pm
(@windadict)
Posts: 153
Mate Registered
 

rch701 wrote: [quote=MN3]$2500 does not seem out of range for a well maintained, newly painted boat.

If the sails are good, and the hulls are strong, and the trailer is in the shape it is claimed ... all seems reasonable to me.

And if you like "Jet Black".

You can find white ones N5.2 for less money, between $950 and $2000, depend how far you want to drive.


 
Posted : May 13, 2013 3:55 pm
Edward Hilliard
(@edchris177)
Posts: 2531
Captain Registered
 

The price is not out of line, but there are some caveats.
I second the comments on black paint in Florida, plus scratches will start to look terrible. On th eothe rhand, if you want to camp with your cat, you will not need a frying pan.
There are a few other points as well. That '79 has the old skinny DS rod/V strap. They were prone to breakage. I have one sitting in my shop that is snapped in half. They also used the 1 1/4" mast ball, not impossible to find/make, but scarce.
Can't tell from the photo, but it probably also has the non captive mast base. Does not appear to have had any upgrades done since '79.
It still has the original centre tube, & I see the beam caps are missing. To me, the value(in the vendors mind) is mostly in the paint & trailer.
It may be in good shape, or, as Phil said on Duck Dynasty, "make up can cover a lot of evil Cole Man."
The 5.2 is no slouch, & carries a pretty good Portsmouth for a mature boat.


 
Posted : May 14, 2013 12:47 am
bill harris
(@coastrat)
Posts: 1292
Member
 

things heard around a black catamaran down south...

"hey you guys mind helping me move my boat?"..."sure man, i'll just grab it F@#K!!! SON-OF-AB%#CH!!! THAT MOTHER IS HOT!!!"

and another ...

CCRREEEEEEK...TICTICTICTIC...POP POP POP....CCCRRRREEEEEEEKKK...TICTICTICTIC..POPPOPOPOP...SIZZLLE SIZZLE SIZZLE...OUCH!!!!! HOLY S@#t!!!


 
Posted : May 14, 2013 2:36 am
(@PurdueZach)
Posts: 223
Mate Registered
Topic starter
 

Thanks guys. I expected your responses but wanted to be sure.

Still on the hunt...I'm looking at probably a newer (90's-00's) Hobie 16 or something of similar size and simplicity.


 
Posted : May 14, 2013 3:57 am
(@klozhald)
Posts: 1461
Master Chief Registered
 

coastrat wrote: "sure man, i'll just grab it F@#K!!! SON-OF-AB%#CH!!! THAT MOTHER IS HOT!!!"

I think I have heard you say that from here in AZ! 🙂


 
Posted : May 14, 2013 4:52 am
(@hyperope)
Posts: 94
Mate Registered
 

$750 would be too much for a black boat.


 
Posted : May 14, 2013 9:13 am
Secret Link