Welcome Guest
Catamaran Sailing at TheBeachcats.com Logo
Notifications
Clear all

Bobbing on a lake on a windless day

26 Posts
9 Users
0 Reactions
10.4 K Views
(@Anonymous 700)
Posts: 213
Topic starter
 
[#12159]

Yesterday the wind died on us completely, so we were sitting on Jordan Lake, and the waves were big enough to bob us up and down uncomfortably.

So ... how is that possible? On a closed lake, what causes waves, if not wind? If there is no wind, how can there be waves of that size?

Jonathan


 
Posted : June 23, 2003 6:29 pm
MaryAWells
(@maryawells)
Posts: 5485
Member
 

Well, Loch Ness has a monster, and Lake Erie has a monster (LEM), so I guess you will have to come up with a name for the Jordan Lake Monster.


 
Posted : June 23, 2003 7:18 pm
(@mauganh17)
Posts: 3089
Captain Registered
 

Motor boaters.

Tons of them.


 
Posted : June 23, 2003 7:43 pm
(@Anonymous 12258)
Posts: 228
 

I think the effect is mostly from motorboat traffic, but is likely to be exaggerated by shoreline shapes.
example : Lake Conroe, in East Texas - a "constant level" lake, i.e. not a reservoir where levels are adjusted dramatically for agricultural needs. In many of the coves or arms of the lakes, the lakefront homeowners have built vertical walls in front of their property, to prevent erosion, have flat lawns, whatever. The effect is remarkable - by 10am, there are standing waves in every cove & arm of the lake, regardless of the wind. It only takes a small amount of boat traffic to start it, and it seems to continue all day.

By contrast, Lake Travis is a reservoir with hugely varying lake levels. But, even when one shoreline is steep, the other is usually a gradual entry. Even on busy motor boat traffic days, once the wakes stop, the waves settle down, too.


 
Posted : June 23, 2003 10:25 pm
(@mauganh17)
Posts: 3089
Captain Registered
 

There are no verticle sea walls on Jordan... only a massive amount of budweiser-powered rednecks on bass boats that think that their penis size is predicated on the size of their outboard.

I'm really not exaggerating either.


 
Posted : June 23, 2003 11:50 pm
Nick Nelson
(@nnelson1)
Posts: 25
Lubber Registered
 

We had the same thing last wekend at Otsego Lake in Gaylord. It was my wife's first time out on the Hobie and, as we sat in the middle of the lake bobbing up and down and not going anywhere, she kept asking, "Is it always like this?"
I had to assure her that, no, it's usually FUN!
It would have been relaxing and a good way to get a tan if it weren't for the plethora of jet skis and powerboats.
Oh, well, hope to get her out on a windy day so I can replace her sniggering with some healthy screams!!

Nick


 
Posted : June 24, 2003 8:10 am
(@Anonymous 37755)
Posts: 772
 

If the water is deep and the wind calm, catamrans make good diving platforms turned on their side.

Call it righting practice, checking to see if your mast is sealed, or washing off the salt if you need to


 
Posted : June 24, 2003 8:40 am
(@Anonymous 37791)
Posts: 397
 
Quote
Motor boaters.

Tons of them.

And, speaking of tons of powerboats, check out this thread from The Hull Truth Boating Forum . . .

Can they hear us now? Good!!!


 
Posted : June 24, 2003 2:50 pm
(@garym)
Posts: 27
Member
 

This is the great tragedy of catamaran sailing in the South--at least in Louisiana and East Texas. By the time it's warm enough to fly hulls up and down the lake without a wetsuit, you have maybe a month or so of good wind before the powercraft and the stifling heat turn the lakes into "Shake and Bake" hell. I wish I had an answer, aside from moving to another place!


 
Posted : June 24, 2003 3:09 pm
(@mauganh17)
Posts: 3089
Captain Registered
 

Wow Kevin... that kind of mentality is exactly the kind we have down here on the little lakes of NC. They get so worked up over how macho they are in their huge, overpowered, little skiff that they don't realize how much of a nuisance and environmental detriment they have become. Not to mention, there is no license requirement for small craft operation in NC, half these idiots don't know right-of-way... their method of collision avoidance is more gas. Last time I was on Lake Jordan, I was almost hit by a PWC, and came close to two others. I really wish I had a Windrider Rave sometimes and just blow past these idiots and make them feel really insignificant.

(I know I sound angry)


 
Posted : June 24, 2003 3:58 pm
MaryAWells
(@maryawells)
Posts: 5485
Member
 

Instead of further aggravating hostility between powerboaters and sailboaters, wouldn't it be better if sailors would go to powerboat meetings and ask whether any of the powerboaters would be interested in helping out with sailing regattas? And also suggest that the two factions get together and hold a few seminars each year to educate powerboaters about sailing and to educate sailors about the needs of powerboaters and to educate both groups about safety concerns when they have to share a small body of water.


 
Posted : June 25, 2003 8:35 am
(@Anonymous 700)
Posts: 213
Topic starter
 
Quote
I think the effect is mostly from motorboat traffic, but is likely to be exaggerated by shoreline shapes.
example : Lake Conroe, in East Texas - a "constant level" lake, i.e. not a reservoir where levels are adjusted dramatically for agricultural needs. In many of the coves or arms of the lakes, the lakefront homeowners have built vertical walls in front of their property, to prevent erosion, have flat lawns, whatever. The effect is remarkable - by 10am, there are standing waves in every cove & arm of the lake, regardless of the wind. It only takes a small amount of boat traffic to start it, and it seems to continue all day.

Sigh. That seems plausible.

I guess that also means we should be very skeptical of wave height as a measure of wind on Lake Jordan.

Jonathan


 
Posted : June 25, 2003 9:41 am
(@mauganh17)
Posts: 3089
Captain Registered
 

The wind will never kick up waves on a body of water like jordan unless its 40+

The waves are there purely because of the motor boaters. They can traverse the whole lake and never lose height, so just be on the lookout for them.

They're actually a benefit on a windless day and you're trying to get back to vista point. You can catch them and ride them for quite a distance if you're good


 
Posted : June 25, 2003 9:43 am
(@Anonymous 700)
Posts: 213
Topic starter
 
Quote
Instead of further aggravating hostility between powerboaters and sailboaters, wouldn't it be better if sailors would go to powerboat meetings and ask whether any of the powerboaters would be interested in helping out with sailing regattas? And also suggest that the two factions get together and hold a few seminars each year to educate powerboaters about sailing and to educate sailors about the needs of powerboaters and to educate both groups about safety concerns when they have to share a small body of water.

Or do you think we could convince them to produce wind instead of waves?

Jonathan


 
Posted : June 25, 2003 10:44 am
(@Anonymous 700)
Posts: 213
Topic starter
 
Quote
They're actually a benefit on a windless day and you're trying to get back to vista point. You can catch them and ride them for quite a distance if you're good

You're saying I can surf on moderate waves in a lake like Jordan? How do I do that?

Jonathan
(who worries that he is being gullible...)


 
Posted : June 25, 2003 10:45 am
(@mauganh17)
Posts: 3089
Captain Registered
 

if the wave is big enough, you wont be able to surf it in the sense that you surf a wave at the coast, but you can have it push you along for a good 15 feet before it passes you. Its way easier to do when you have wind... but I've done it a handful of times in windless days. (like today)


 
Posted : June 25, 2003 11:08 am
PrindleFish
(@prindlefish)
Posts: 14
Member
 

I used to have the loud fast powerboats but then one night a friend took me sailing with a full moon on Lake Travis in central Tx and my life was changed forever. There is nothing like sailing, wind or no wind. I just make sure there is more beer on days when the wind is light, and then kick back and enjoy the wildlife.(see attachment) Not to mention my boat kitty is much larger now that I don't have to buy a $100 worth of gas on every outing. Give me my Catalina 27 and my 16ft Prindle over any powerboat any day.
Born Again Boater.,. ,.,}=)))*>


 
Posted : June 26, 2003 8:50 pm
 danb
(@danb)
Posts: 252
Mate Registered
 

we have kayaks and paddle when the wind dies. powerboat wakes become surfing opportunities! at our regatta last weekend my friend tena was at the leeward mark in her yak to cheer us around the mark, then she paddled straight upwind to the windward mark finish line, she was waiting for us at the finish with cold coronas. what a woman! kayaks- i find myself paddling more and more. a great way to be on the water especially if the wind is too light- or heavy- for sailing


 
Posted : June 27, 2003 6:51 am
Bob Klein
(@bob-klein)
Posts: 107
Member
 

I agree with the Kayak idea. We bought a demo Hobie Mirage from Key Sailing. What a blast and great exercise for the legs. We take it along when we go sailing for those times when the kids get bored or when the winds die. Just sit back, gab the rudder handle to steer and peddle your touché off. Of course, we are constantly on the lookout for power boaters and jetskies as we sit rather low in the water. The thing is pretty fast if you have strong legs!

Final comment; my kids actually like it when the winds die. They simply use the boat as a large raft from which they dive and do flips into the water.

Bob Klein
Inter 18 + Hobie Kayak


 
Posted : June 27, 2003 10:13 am
MaryAWells
(@maryawells)
Posts: 5485
Member
 

You're right about kayaks being hard to see because they sit so low in the water. Isn't there something similar to a bicycle flag to make it more visible? Kevin ought to know.


 
Posted : June 27, 2003 11:00 am
(@Anonymous 37791)
Posts: 397
 
Quote
You're right about kayaks being hard to see because they sit so low in the water. Isn't there something similar to a bicycle flag to make it more visible? Kevin ought to know.

[Linked Image]

Yes, there is a product similar to the bicycle flags. There was quite the hubbub on the Maine coast several years back, though, when a piece of legislation was introduced that would require them on kayaks in the state. (In Maine, it was the commercial fishermen who complained about not being able to see the kayakers.)

Perhaps the best thing a paddler can do to enhance saftety in busy waterways is to simply stay clear of the high traffic areas. One of the beautiful things about the sea kayak is that it can take you into the nooks and crannies that a deeper draft boat can't. (You've still got to deal with the hot rodding jet skis, though.)

Under the rules of the road, a kayak has no special place in the pecking order and is considered simply a "vessel" under the definitions, contrary to what some paddlers think about a human-powered boat having rights similar to a sailboat. A paddler in a kayak has to deal with the fact that they are nearly invisible to other craft, especially on a windy day when the whitecaps are kicked up. For me, rule number one is the "tonage rule". If it's bigger than me, I stay out of its way, no matter who technically has the right. I paddle with the notion that I'm invisible to other boats and maintain constant watch when in busy waters.

When sea kayaks were starting gaining popularity a couple decades ago, the most common colors were red and yellow, for good reason. They are highly visible. Same with PFD's and paddling jackets. Then, there was this trend toward colors that blended right in with the water. Blues and greens are real tough to see. Myself, I paddle a boat with a bright yellow deck and a white hull. My PFD is yellow, too. Really helps to stand out. Yellow or red blades on the paddle are really helpful since they are in constant motion and show up much better than a flag on the boat.

Oh, I forgot to mention the reason I don't like the flags. I spend a lot of time in my kayak with the hull side up. A lot of the fun I have in the boat is practicing various rolling techniques. (Greenland rolling competitions feature over 30 variations of the Eskimo roll.) Those flags and their whip sticks just don't come around too well.


 
Posted : June 27, 2003 1:02 pm
Bob Klein
(@bob-klein)
Posts: 107
Member
 

Kevin;

Do you have a web address where I can order one of these flags (and how do they mount)? My Kayak is simple white and not very visible.

Thanks in advance

bob


 
Posted : June 27, 2003 1:35 pm
(@h17windbtch6333)
Posts: 147
Mate Registered
 

go-fast boats can have the windless baking hot days of summer. They usually will not want to deal with wind and chop. So this works out for me as the wind pick up, they go home. I guess this doesnt apply to small lakes.


 
Posted : June 27, 2003 4:09 pm
(@Anonymous 37791)
Posts: 397
 
Quote
go-fast boats can have the windless baking hot days of summer . . .

Here's our go-fast powerboat on a windless, hot summer day with my 10-year-old at the helm.

The next day (yesterday), the winds were up around 20 and the sailing was a bit more lively aboard two hulls.

[Linked Image]


 
Posted : June 30, 2003 9:38 pm
(@Anonymous 37791)
Posts: 397
 
Quote
Kevin;

Do you have a web address where I can order one of these flags (and how do they mount)? My Kayak is simple white and not very visible.

Thanks in advance

bob

Bob,

I searched for a current source of the flags, but couldn't find one on the web. I still see them on the water occasionally, but don't know where people are finding them. The one I showed in the picture was called a "sea flag" and was manufactured in Vancouver a few years back.


 
Posted : June 30, 2003 9:41 pm
PrindleFish
(@prindlefish)
Posts: 14
Member
 

Nice CatBoat. I want one of those someday. They look like a lot of fun. My motor is an Atomic 4 on my Catalina 27. It comes in real handy on those windless days. But as soon as the wind picks up the sails come out.
}=)))*>


 
Posted : June 30, 2003 11:46 pm
Secret Link