Welcome Guest
Catamaran Sailing at TheBeachcats.com Logo
Notifications
Clear all

Carbon Wings?

8 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
1,767 Views
DVL
 DVL
(@dvl)
Posts: 160
Mate Registered
Topic starter
 
[#11462]

Has anyone made a set of wing struts/mounts out of carbon fiber or fiberglass instead of aluminum tubing. I would think that the wing frames would or could be stronger and lighter than the stock aluminum set. Anyone have a design available? What would be the risks?
I'm thinking that a set of wings for my H-18 may help me get the wife & kids sailing more.


 
Posted : February 17, 2003 8:49 pm
(@catman)
Posts: 1600
Master Chief Registered
 

Lets see. Hobie wings for a 18 are about 1500 bucs. Could you imagine what carbon would cost?


 
Posted : February 17, 2003 9:35 pm
(@mauganh17)
Posts: 3089
Captain Registered
 

If I had come across a large surplus of carbon fiber cloth, I'd try it, but like said above, it'd be damn expensive.

That being said, I've come across some CF inexpensively, and I'm going to make a new bow foil out of it for my 17.


 
Posted : February 17, 2003 11:18 pm
 grob
(@grob)
Posts: 541
Chief Registered
 

Those wings can't be aluminium as it should cost:-

Aluminium Tube is about $5/kg x 10kg = $50
Carbon fibre tube is about $50/kg x 10kg = $500

Perhaps they are made from silver
$150/kg x 10kg = $1500

Yep thats it, Cunning devils those guys at Hobie!


 
Posted : February 18, 2003 7:37 am
(@teamteets)
Posts: 215
Mate Registered
 

At Texel a few years back there were several boats that used a broken carbon mast section to make wings. They would drill and insert a tube from from the beam end through the mast groove. Glass it all together and sand. May one of the the folks from the Netherlands have some pictures?


 
Posted : February 18, 2003 8:18 am
(@Anonymous 7986)
Posts: 264
 

In my own personal experiance with carbon fiber vs. aluminum, you are not going to lose a bunch of weight. Aluminum alloys we use are very close to the weight of carbon fiber and are much cheaper, easier to work with and easier to fix. We can match the weight of carbon fiber on some applications by drilling out non-load bearing sections and butting others.

H-18 wings are pretty light to begin with. I don't see the performance advantage in using carbon fiber in this application.


 
Posted : February 18, 2003 3:37 pm
(@todd_sails)
Posts: 1149
Member
 

did you know that CF conducts electicity?

If Hobie made it, they'd just add a 'comp-tip' to it!




 
Posted : February 18, 2003 4:20 pm
(@catman)
Posts: 1600
Master Chief Registered
 

I just want to add, you will enjoy having wings.They make the boat larger,give you drier place to sit and add extra righting moment adding safety when the the breeze picks up. I had the old style wings. With the solid covers they weighed in at 36lbs.

Have Fun
Mike


 
Posted : February 18, 2003 5:00 pm
Secret Link