edit: I got one side of the story on the 10% penalty, and I'm trying to get the other. Sounds pretty damn Mickey Mouse so far... the RC from another course protested a N17 for passing too close to their race circle... and the protest was upheld.
Not that gem again...
What circle? PM me if needed.
BTW, why did Enrique's score change to RET for Race 4?
Mike
Seems to me that it would be tough to hold competitors accountable when RC's set up courses that have overlapping laylines.
edit: I got one side of the story on the 10% penalty, and I'm trying to get the other. Sounds pretty damn Mickey Mouse so far... the RC from another course protested a N17 for passing too close to their race circle... and the protest was upheld.
Not that gem again...
What circle? PM me if needed.
BTW, why did Enrique's score change to RET for Race 4?
Mike
Seems to me that it would be tough to hold competitors accountable when RC's set up courses that have overlapping laylines.
Perhaps the competitor should protest the RC who set their course right in his way?!
I christen thee, the Flying Wasp!
Hey, you scratched my anchor!
http:/
I've got a 16yr. old daughter named Sara, I'm trying to talk her into driving for me...oh, and she weighs about 100lbs!
I think I'm going to rename my boat Sarah.
The incident apparently occurred when Matt and Sarah were not racing - the circles are unlikely to overlap with the calibre of RC onsite, but the cats have to sail quite a distance at this venue to get to their circle. Someone felt infringed upon...
Negative, Ghostrider. The pattern is full.
Beth's gonna be pissed when I start calling her Sarah!
That's the quote of the week right there!
Edit: Although, if it makes you start winning races, she may not mind as much...
Mike
OK, that makes more sense.

http:/
1 USA 31 NEWBERRY, Sarah CASEY, John [3] 1 1 1 1 1 5.00 1
2 USA 38 STREATER, Sarah WHITEHEAD, Matthew 1 [4/10%](1) 2 2 2 2 9.00 2
3 USA 23 REISS, Taylor LIHAN, Sarah 2 [6] 3 3 6 3 17.00 3
4 USA 42 TARTAGLINO, Sandra FARRAR, Jonathan [5] 4 4 4 3 4 19.00 4
5 PUR 29 FIGUEROA, Enrique MALATRASI, Carla 4 2 6 [8/RET] 5 6 23.00 5
6 CAN 30 RAMSAY, Luke GIRKE, Nikola 6 [7] 7 6 4 5 28.00 6
7 USA 25 BERGAN, Lindsay BERGAN, Dalton [8/RET] 5 5 5 7 7 29.00 7

Look like CAN got the same, lame (IMO) penalty - www.regattanetwork.com/
Mike, I just find it very hard to credit a N17 making the particularly long trek back to the catamaran boat park would be dumb enough to interfere with another fleet's race. Both protests were filed by the RC - I'm sure you learned, as I did, that the RC's job is to provide a level playing field and ONLY file against a competitor in the event no OTHER competitor was in a position to see a rule infraction. Granted, I don't know all the facts found, but certainly the first penalty seems (from witness accounts) to have been uncalled for. There seems a potential of a PRO on another course with an over-inflated sense of importance. It would take a serious infraction that affected sailors on my course for me to reach into another fleet's standings.
So, are you saying that the second penalty is for breaking the same rule?
Without being there, it's hard to take sides, but I've seen this before, and was able to talk the PRO off the cliff just enough to avoid a protest or worse. You don't want to know what the other judges were saying before I spoke up and shut it down...
Mike

More pix in this gallery: http://sailingpix.photoshelter.com/...
- 57 Forums
- 31.6 K Topics
- 345.9 K Posts
- 1,732 Online
- 31.1 K Members
